54.7 hours played
Written 17 days ago
Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag is remembered very fondly by the community, both by fans of the older, pre-RPG era (some would even say, pre-unity) and by fans of the newer games. It is the first AC title which focuses on not just the assassin fantasy, but an entirely different one as well: Piracy. It is fair to call AC4 not just an AC title, but a standalone pirate game; many, including myself, would go further and say that AC4 is the best pirate game ever made.
Let's focus on its flaws:
AC4 is the worst representative of the counter mechanic of any pre-Origins game. Whereas in other games, the counter-kill served to fulfill the fantasy of playing as a master of all lethal forms of combat, allowing a break from more thoughtful combat in favor of stylish and cinematic blood fests (especially well done in AC3), AC4 does not function without the counter-kill. The counter window is large enough to 100% complete AC Valhalla twice and leaves enough time to finish the years of therapy required to cope with having played that bore of a game. It is mind-numbingly stupid. In all other AC games prior, the player was confined to stealth, not just out of the instrinsic motivation to stylishly creep around, killing enemies without being seen and then hiding in plain sight to escape any enemy left alive to witness you, but also by respect of large numbers of guards fighting you. You never wanted to enter overt combat with masses of guards because it was actually dangerous, so the player is motivated to keep the upper hand by not being seen. In AC4, you never have that worry. It does not matter how many enemies are fighting you, you're Edward Kenway after all, father of Haytham Kenway and Grandfather of Connor Kenway. You feel like a cartoonishly strong beserk, though not intimidating, like in AC3 with Connor, but just unbalanced and broken. It's just not fun.
Then comes the bugs. THE BUGS. I am only mentioning combat and bugs as flaws, but trust me, the bugs count as an entire game's worth of flaws. To put it simply: AC4 is broken. You sheathe swords in the middle of combat, enemies don't register that you're in combat with them, you clip through walls, you cannot FOR THE LIFE OF YOU dare to traverse the upper masts of any ship during a boarding because 5/10 times Edward will decide that you actually didn't want to hang onto a rope and instead fall to your death during a level 60 Man'o'War boarding. Your weapons don't make sounds, and if they do, they do it too late. There is an actual skill ceiling for the parkour: Over time, you just learn which objects will cause Edward to have a seizure and how to avoid them efficiently. That is not satisfying. Over time, you learn to block out these bugs mentally, you learn instinctively how to avoid objects and routes that will trigger them, but they are there. After finishing the game, you can enjoy the DLCs: Aveline and Freedom Cry. And after you finished those too, you can maybe waltz around the Abstergo offices and complete all hacking minigames. And after all THAT, you can try out the ridiculously and unjustifiably fleshed-out Multiplayer of AC4. Don't worry, you will encounter all of these bugs there too. You will ask yourself the following question multiple times: "What on earth have Ubisoft been smoking to work on SO MUCH DLC just to leave the base game like it has been coded on LSD?????" It's stupid.
P.S.: Prepare to sign into Ubisoft Connect EACH time you launch AC4. You cannot circumvent this. Also, Edwards fleet is stupid. Not being able to skip the boring mobile-game-esque ship battles is stupid. Missions going on for real time DAYS is stupid.
What it does VERY good is everything else. Story, pacing, ship combat, visuals, NPCs, characters, post-game, etc. Talking about all of those in detail would take too long, feel free to watch Whitelight's review of AC4 on YouTube.
In conclusion, AC4 is not a master-piece, nor is it perfect. I don't even think it's the best AC game. It's deeply and frustratingly flawed. But all it does good, it does amazingly. And despite all of this, it is the best pirate game ever made, and one of the most enjoyable games you'll probably play.