Coral Island

I used to love this game, but its like they dont want us to love it. Romance (?) is not romance. Dull, boring. nothing about you. You cant even care about them because they dont care about you too. For example one of the bachelors just talks about his brother and all of his heart events are full of them. Nothing is about you, usually you are not even on the screen they just talk w each other. There is almost no lore, or meaning. And if u do 10 heart, still nothing. They act like you are a random person. No depth no romance. Feels so empty and boring. Money system is absolute disaster. I just sold my golden egg which is very rare (even has its own achievement) and i got 250 coin for LARGE GOLDEN EGG. LITERAL GOLD. But they ask you 40.000 coin for auto-petter or auto-hay. Wonderful right? FISHING. Ive never ever seen worse. I cant even explain it just... its so bad. Lots of bugs. Some of them makes the game unplayable. Animations are bad too. I am also game dev and artist and i am sorry to say but ik its not that hard to make watering animation or sleeping. Sleeping animation is same w dying, fun isnt it. U just get hit by had and fall. This game has so much potential but it feels like target audience is 5 year olds. No depth in dialogues, you dont matter, just do chores and get sleep. At first it was fun because u thinl you can grow but nuh huh. I really REALLYYY wanted to love romanceable characters and some of them are cutie potatoes but i cant event get close to them. When u can be bf and gf, they just say thanks and if u talk them in daily life they still act like you are a random farmer. Endgame. Well, after 1 year or one and half, things get so boring. And doesnt makes sense. For example there is an item you can get after getting rich, but it needs a very early game items. Or after a long grind u get keg, to make wine. First u make a juice, then u make a wine with that, 2 steps and DAYYSSSSS. And you sell it for like 700 or so. uhmmm...sure.... I completed all the mines and the prize was 600 gold and 10 explosives WHICH i could craft already. See my point? You can mine but it gives you nothing, again. Money reward is credibly low. Rewards are terrrrrribbbleee. Usually just candy or very little coin. Nothing to do after some point. I dont recommend at least before they fix things. (Game has so much potential and cool features that i love, but no depth. I really hope they change dialogues and some other things, then it will be perf)

I really wanted to love this game. Visually, it's stunning. Easily the best-looking farming sim out there, hands down. The character designs, environments, and overall aesthetic are beautiful. There's also a ton of stuff to do, with the merfolk content adding great longevity, and some genuinely fantastic festivals full of outfits and collectibles. However, despite multiple attempts to fully dive in, I repeatedly found myself losing interest. This last time, I really gave it a serious push, and initially, I genuinely enjoyed myself. Clearing the ocean and seeing the beach transform was rewarding visually, but then the townsfolk barely reacted. They'd casually remark, "Interesting, the beach is clean now.. cool!" and then immediately go back to treating you like just some random farmer. You can literally become the most successful person in town, and yet the townspeople only drop a couple of generic lines and then completely ignore your accomplishments. It makes your efforts feel completely pointless. The characters themselves are disappointingly shallow and stuck in Disney-esque scenarios. It's honestly frustrating how juvenile their storylines feel, especially considering most of the player base likely grew up on Harvest Moon and are now adults. One character’s entire plot revolves around a baking contest, and their next four cutscenes obsessively focus only on that. There's nothing meaningful about who they are, why they're in the town, or their motivations; just repetitive, superficial dialogue. Gameplay-wise, the fishing mechanic is terrible. I absolutely loved fishing in Stardew Valley, but here it felt so broken that I just leveled up to 10 using nets instead. Bug-catching isn't any better; the cone radius feels awkwardly narrow and inaccurate. You’ll clearly be right on top of a bug, but somehow miss entirely, and it just flies away. It makes zero sense and is consistently frustrating. Combat has potential but suffers badly from hit detection issues. Enemies on new floors often remain asleep and invincible for the first five seconds, then suddenly wake up and attack unpredictably, which makes cave diving feel annoying rather than exciting. Automation is a bright spot. I really appreciate features like large chests, auto-petters, auto-grabbers, and general quality-of-life improvements. These do enhance the experience, but they aren't enough to overcome the other glaring flaws. Ultimately, the game still feels like it's stuck in beta. It was so close to becoming one of my favorite games ever, but ended up feeling disappointingly shallow. If I don’t care about the town or its characters, why am I even playing?

i like this game! ONLY one thing i do not like, is theres only one way to save i dont wanna lose certain achievements bc i didnt go to bed before i exited the game.

This is a mixed review that leans positive. Characters are great, gameplay is fun and interesting, but man, how is it still so terribly bug riddled? I consistently find my animals possessed and floating in the sky. Enemy hitboxes still need a ridiculous amount of work. I really hope this game gets some more bug fixes and care put into QoL.

i loveee this game so much. probably my favorite of the farming sims I've played, which is why it's SO ANNOYING that the devs still can't seem to sort out the bugs or flesh out the content more. the environment is great, i didn't even mind repeatedly cleaning the water for hours on end. However, the character interactions and story line need more work. Can't recommend other people to spend their money on this until the developers clean the game up, which i really hope they do.

replaced stardew valley as my favourite. stardew is very close 2nd still but coral island devs are awesome and enjoyed every minute of playing coral island. would have played more but recently got into other games but constantly wanting to return and start new save.

36 hours in to this game after owning it for 3 days I can safely say 10/10. Definitely a farm/quest/grind kind of game I would say its almost like animal crossing for adults since you can have a romance life and own animals. I recommend this game to anyone who loves a great farm/life game.

I have been searching for years for a decent farming/life sim to succeed Stardew Valley and I think I've finally found it. Up until now, most games lost my interest or run out of content quickly, but this one really seems to have it all and then some. There is so much content to explore, tons of townsfolk (and cute animals) to get to know, mines to explore, an ocean floor to clean up and explore, many pets that you can adopt (you can have multiple pets at a time now too). The game is no longer in Early Access, but they still release major updates and have big plans for more (multiplayer, children growing up, etc.). Definitely a very full game to play now, with lots to look forward to.

First things first this game is janky, it's something you have to accept if you want to enjoy it. You will miss swings at enemies, the weird black noodles will stutter across your screen, and you will certainly miss catching that skittish bug who's obviously in the catch radius and is glowing green. It also has followed Stardew's formula in some really strange ways but not other important ways. For instance, does the blacksmith randomly show up and give you furnace blueprints, of course he does. Yet at the same time they have managed to completely miss making the mines a fun place to be and instead each mine floor has like 2 ore total and there's almost never anything else to be found. The combat also feels super weird, most enemies just sort of phase right through you and don't really respond to being hit. Often times you just trade blows with an enemy until you inevitably win, and even if you do manage to kill an enemy it will still continue its attack animation and hit you even after it has already died. Fishing too kinda sucks, the only strategy for catching fish is have a good fishing rod and hold click when the fish is chilling and click when the fish is angry. I wish they would have followed the Stardew formula a bit more in those key aspects of the game and less in the random story elements and things that pop up that are blatantly inspired / directly taken from Stardew. I think this game sometimes struggles to have its own identity and with the balance between new cool systems and borrowed ones from other games can be a little wacky. Where this game really shines is in the characters and world. Every character has their own charm and pretty unique interests and story. There's also so many characters that I have found myself even a year into the game getting a letter in the mail and having to look up who the person sending the mail even is. I've never really had the struggle in games like this wondering who I will romance but due to so many of the characters being intriguing and charming you can find yourself second guessing. The artwork for the characters and the entire game really is also top notch. This game really does take you to its own little world and invites you to interact with characters who really feel like they live within it. On top of that there is so much to do and explore. Overall, this game has some unique charm even though it is a little janky and grindy at times. I have really enjoyed my time with it and would recommend it to others who like the life sim/ farming sim types games as it definitely scratches that itch. At the same time you have to be ready for some jank and lack of polish with some aspects of the game and be open minded. This is no perfect masterpiece like Stardew Valley but it does have its moments! PS if I ever have to clean up another piece of trash in the vast sea of jittery little tentacles and impossible to find solar ball things I'm gonna lose my mind.

Coral Island was a blast - super relaxing, beautiful world, and great characters. I played it to 100% and enjoyed every minute of it.

very much like stardew, but personally, i like that its not pixel art.

The moment I saw the trailer a few years back, I couldn't take my eyes off of it. When I finally got the game a month or two after its release, I was immediately hooked. Players have their own perception for what a good farming simulator is for them, but this one captured my heart and thus is my favorite out of all. The game is rich in story unlike most farming simulators I've played, and it's obvious how this game was made with a lot of love. Here are the specifics of what I like about the game. I'll also be putting a few cons that could be improved in the future, should the devs choose to. Pros - Equal amount of stories, interactions, and game play. I think what made me so burnt out with Stardew was the fact that it was so grindy, but I understand that it was really designed like that. This is more based on my preference. I love that I have time to interact with the characters and know more about their rich lores, as well as the island's, while also having the time to complete tasks and do other stuff for my farm. Never felt pressured in this game. - In connection with the previous pro, the tasks in this game aren't difficult BUT it'll take up most of your time as a lot tasks, like gathering materials, can be quite time-consuming, and most of your builds need items that you can't easily buy from the stores. - Characters are diverse, and each of them have their own unique story. I love the cut-scenes because they feel so personal, though it's a little awkward for a farmer who's literally a stranger to be able to witness it lmao. - I LOVE THE NEW UI. It tells me who's birthday it is, if there are new cut-scenes, and it's overall just so cute and a big leap from the previous UI. - This game has the prettiest environment. Unrealistic, so to speak, especially for a struggling town if this was real life, but the interiors of ALL houses are so carefully decorated, and the all the other places just feel so alive. It gives me some sort of an escape from the ugly aah world I live in. - I love the conveyor belt/auto chest. You don't know how helpful that thing is. Cons - Foraging and mining are a little bit underwhelming. I'd need a lot of essences or bars for different things, but I an only gather so much so I'll only ever get a few at a time. - A little bit of bugs here and there, but I've been voicing them out in the official Discord server and the devs are very accommodating. - I wish there were a few changes in the cut scenes where they involve dialogues about the connection between the player and the character. While I'm invested in their lores, I think it's kinda sad that the player is only ever a witness to their, uh, problems. Or like helps them go through this and that. - In relation to that, please make more dialogues for characters as they increase hearts. - The concept of making seeds first AND needing to ship 50 of the sea crops each are, imo, unnecessary. I just don't see the point of it. Give this game a try! And for the devs, thank you for creating this masterpiece and pls make more dialogues since that is where Coral Island, for me, is known for.

Super cute, fun game. It has its bugs, but the game makes it worth dealing with <3

I absolutely love this game so far! The graphics are adorable, the characters are charming, and the story is really interesting! My only wish is that there was better and more in depth character customization, such as more hairstyles, eye types, body types, and face types. I just feel like I can't really immerse myself when the character looks nothing like me. Other less important notes (just stuff that I think would be cool to have in the game for funzies) maybe like CG's with the dateable characters and maybe some for the main storyline? Also more merfolk options to romance cause I am OBSESSED with their lore and story!!!

Fun game and a lot more polished than a lot of other farming games that arent stardew valley, but its a bit grindy sometimes, ESPECIALLY when you get to the ocean. After I unlocked an area that you get to in diving I thought I was finally through with the grind, just to find out you have to keep grinding the same boring minigame for another 10 hours at least. Everything else is done pretty well and is pretty fun and steady with gameplay, but the area where you get to diving just makes the game feel like it comes to a screeching halt. Reccomend but be careful not to get burnt out in that part of the game.

One of the best farming games ever. A lot of variety of plants although a lot of people to date.Like the feeling to go to the town and meet new people,I can although buy a lot of farming pets.Lot of buildings and restaurants. I never feel bored to play this awesome game.

Best Farming Sim game to ever exist. The town center even has a pride flag on it. Very diverse set of characters and although the game is a collection of past sim games, I feel as though this has it's own character.

Game does not properly work, will crash constantly once it reaches loading screen. i suggest, to be cautious as i bought this game and it has been acting this way since day one...will not be buying anymore games from this again for if this one crashes don't know if others will. Was really looking forward to playing it but sadly it just is not meant to be. Hope the bugs get fixed to stop it from crashing.

Imagine part Stardew Valley and part Animal crossing with your own spin on Polynesian and eco theme. Love the game play so far and the animals are a fun addition to catch and interact with.

This game is adorable and so cozy! I love going between my farm, the town, the mines, and the ocean for all kinds of quests and errands. The NPC art is beautiful!

such a cute relaxing game, it has adorable little cut scenes.

Great game along the lines of Harvest Moon and Stardew Valley . Plus the added ability to go underwater and farm there eventually , Mermaids included . Plenty of animals to look after and crops to grow , Plus activities each season and once you get to know other characters you can go on little events with them .

very fun, the map takes some getting use to, the quest keep me engaged, bug keeping and fishing are great money makers at first.

Coral Island stands out with its original blend of farming, ocean exploration, and environmental restoration. The gameplay feels fresh and meaningful, with unique activities like reef cleanup and underwater treasure hunting. It’s a wholesome journey where every action helps the island thrive,and let’s not forget about the mermaids this game is perfect for me i love it so much!! 🪸🏝️

I've started a few different runs of Coral Island, and every time, it ends up losing its appeal pretty quickly. Even with steady updates, the game still feels incomplete. I respect that it's a labor of love and that the devs are working hard, but it’s frustrating to see features like multiplayer added before the core game play feels solid. The character customization has some nice elements, but most of the clothing options are awkward and poorly fitted. Romance in the game also feels dull and surface-level, with little payoff or emotional depth. The combat is also boring and doesn't provide any real challenge. There’s no real tension or variety, and it just feels like something you go through the motions with. The world looks great, and the story is fine, but overall, the game still feels kind of empty. It’s missing the depth and polish that would make it truly engaging. Every time there's an update, I get hopeful and re-download it, only to feel bored again fairly quickly. At this point, I don’t plan to revisit it until it’s out of early access. I’d love to play the finished version someday, but for now, it just feels like a letdown. Despite sinking a lot of hours into this game already, I really can't recommend it in its current state.

The characters, story, and setting are lovely, but the gameplay can be quite tedious and even frustrating. The currency system and drop rate is not very rewarding in my personal opinion, and makes accumulating money difficult, especially when almost everything has a cost, and the cost can be incredibly high (tool upgrades, tools and machines that make things like cooking or processing materials possible, etc.). The cost of cosmetics and aesthetic upgrades/changes is also quite high. All-in-all it's enjoyable to a degree but I personally find it hard to truly relax and enjoy playing when it feels like the rewards are so sparse and you really have to grind to get the kinds of things you want or need. Compared to other games with the same concept, I find this one less rewarding in terms of the currency system and drop rates, which becomes a reason not to play it. It's a shame because I'd love to play more consistently for more of the characters and story, I just find it hard to do so when it feels like I have to constantly grind in order to achieve very basic things.

I love this game because all the graphics are pleasant. Love talking to the NPC. The new adventure you go on and above all I love to decorate my farm. Customize my character is a lot of fun and allowing you to change into other cloths and buying what you want to wear. There is so much and you just don't want to stop the time will fly by.

This game ticks every box that players are looking for ... Love that it challenges you yet also no sense of hurry to accomplish . A game that keeps you coming back without boring you with the same things to do over and over. Lots to do lots to accomplish just plain lots of fun at your pace in your time. Love the game!

This game is a lot of fun, simple to get the hang of and so many romance options. Stories a lot of fun and easy to lose hours to this game.

The game itself looks beautiful in such a lovely, relaxing setting based on Indonesian landscape. And I've really enjoyed getting to build relationships with the NPCs and follow their storylines. But I have to admit, this game is such a grind. I've continued to play out of sheer stubbornness and desire to complete everything rather than because it's fun. I am not used to games where you break the same rocks in a dungeon over and over for 40 floors with the hope of one randomly being the item you need and whether its rocks or trash, that's %50 of the game. If that type of game play does not bother you, then this is perfect for you! For me, it's been repetitive and frustrating but I've been committed for so long, that I'm seeing this one through.

The most stressful part of this game is trying to pick which villager to marry. You move to an island of baddies and you can only pick one </3

The game is so addicting! But I hate it when it crashes several times a day

game is worth it to buy if u are really into a lot of activities in a cozy game. bought this game since demo andd kudos to the devs. cute animals n npcs, there are a lot to look forward to in each dev update. not a fan of in game textures tho but it'll work 9.5/10

Just feels so lonely playing this game, cant find any of the characters they is just no connection with them I like how big the map is but its just so much running around I played this game so long ago with the first release and it feels just the same idk sorry i wish i could like it more

This is the best game known to man ever. From the music too the environment. It's perfection.

Love love love this game! It's so cozy and relaxing. The story line is great and the aesthetics are beautiful!

This is the longest I ever spent on a farming game, 224 hours. I really enjoyed it! I'm still not even 100% done, I could go back and do more, but I'm really happy with how much joy and entertainment this game gave me. Would recommend to any farm game lovers.

One of the best farming games I've played. This game is so polished, I can never go back to Stardew Valley. Sound effects are rewarding and it drives me to keep farming. And there's also a whole underwater region, it's awesome. I haven't really run into any major bugs either, so it's been great! And I absolutely love to just teleport around town, saves so much time.

I like the stardew valley feel, but with more options for adventure. Oh! And mermaids. The five year old in me is quite pleased that I get to play mermaids on the computer again and have it be respectable.

This game is like a great mix of Stardew Valley, Animal Crossing/Sims. The art is so great and detailed. This is one of the best designs of mermaids I have seen. This has been the only farming game that I find as much fun as Stardew Valley.

This game is essentially a better version of Stardew Valley. You have a farm, grow crops, meet villagers, increase relationships, etc. It is better because there is more content and there is a truly diverse set of villagers. It also looks beautiful.

This is by far my favorite farming sim! The diversity, all the events, all the quest, everything is extensive and full. Don't even get me started on how amazing the characters are. Absolutely looking forward to new updates! It is the gift that just keeps giving.

I love the variety of things you can do!! I also think combat is kind of fun, which is very new for me. I love the diving option, and how many characters there are to interact with! I feel like I stumble into parts of the story after getting to a certain spot, and it's really fun to see them all interact. I'm having a great time playing so far!

Like Stardew Valley but some new mechanics, better graphics.

It's so pretty! The mechanics just make sense and don't get me started on how much dash adds to the quality of life! Love this game!

It was a good game, until it forced you the choice to become a merfolk just to push forward the narrative. These types of "forced choices" is lazy writing.

Gamenya bagus cuman sebagai pemain dari indonesia saya cuman mau membutuh fitur pengganti bendera. Ga usah dihapus benderannya cuman bisa di tukar" aj udah cukup kok 😃

Stardew but with scuba gear! 🧑‍🌾🐟 Planted some crops, cleaned the ocean, flirted with half the town. 10/10 would get distracted by cows again. Beautiful, cozy, and eco-friendly — like if *The Sims* went on a tropical vacation and never came back. Still a few bugs, but who cares? Even the bugs are vibing. 😎

It's literally just Stardew Valley in a different font. It's amazing

Absolutely love this game, can't wait for more updates!