59.7 hours played
Written 29 days ago
Sanoba Witch is in my opinion the third-best Yuzu Soft title I've played so far—right behind Dracu-Riot! that still holds a special place in my heart and Café Stella. While Sanoba Witch offers a more character-driven experience, I found that emphasis came at the cost of narrative depth, which somewhat made it a bit more... boring.
That said, Ayachi’s route stood out in a big way. It had suspense, emotional weight, and a kind of tension that kept me genuinely invested. It was the only route that gave me that feeling of nervous intrigue. The other heroines’ stories felt more formulaic in comparison: a gradual romance leading to intimacy, without much narrative weight behind it.
I’m not saying the romance or H-scenes are inherently bad, I enjoy them as much as any lonely man, but I missed the stakes and world-building that made Dracu-Riot! so compelling. It wasn't just about love and sex. And okay, Sanoba Witch has focus in other things, like dealing with depression, finding out yourself and stuff, but still, the feeling that it leaves is that it's all about love.
The H-scenes sometimes felt forced, especially in characters like Kariya’s. While I liked her as a character, her arc didn't naturally lead into intimacy, it just seemed that they turned a switch to lovely mode. It felt like the writers added sex scenes because they had to, not because they fit her story. Her route had everything to be cute, not horny. I'd say she's the only character that, honestly, didn't need h content. I'd say it's almost the same for Tsumugi, but her longer route made it more convincing.
And I didn't like Togakushi's route just because I really, really wanted to see her accepting Koshiji's feeling and having a relationship with her, not with the mc, so I'll childishly say her route is bad. Justice for Koshiji!
So for my overall opinion:
Routes: Ayachi >= Inaba > Kariya = Tsumugi >>> Togakushi
Romance: 8
Scenario: 6 (lacked depth)
Character design: 9
Voice acting: 9 (Would be 10, but I really couldn't like Tsumugi's voice)
Soundtrack: 10
Translation: 10