19.3 hours played
Written 11 days ago
I'm not a fan of this game. In terms of gameplay it takes many steps back from the previous two. It only allows you to have two weapons at a time in the base game, unlike the previous BioShock games that allow you to have the entire arsenal at one time. For me this disincentivized me from trying new weapons. Apparently the DLC, Burial at Sea, implemented a weapon wheel but unless I missed something, there was no tutorial or tooltip in-game to show this and I only learned about it after I'd already given up on playing it and checked the Wikipedia page. Infinite also removes manual saving, which is stupid. Having an autosave feature is great, 1 and 2 did also. Removing the manual saving entirely to only have autosaves is not. In one of the longest sections of the game, I got stuck on some geometry and couldn't move or escape. The last autosave was thirty minutes before, so I had to redo thirty minutes worth of play. If the game had manual saving that still could have happened, but it would have been my fault and that would have been better than being screwed over by the game. Infinite also has no in-game map which annoyed me immensely, I like combing over these games and doing everything I can, but not having a map made it way easier to miss things.
In terms of the story, without getting into spoilers too much it goes for a multiverse story which quickly becomes convoluted. It plays both the authoritarian, racist government and the resistance to said government as both equally evil and has the resistance do some awful things for next to no reason, which left a bad taste in my mouth. There's also a huge twist at the end of the game that I felt made no sense logistically.
Overall, Infinite is my least favorite game in the series. I don't know the history of its development so I don't know if this is the case or not, but to me it feels like the devs were cooking up a game that wasn't in the BioShock series only for the higher-ups to force them to include some references at the end and in the DLC and slap on the BioShock name for marketing. Before playing Infinite I was interested to see what a potential BioShock 4 might be like, but now I have no hope for it.