99.1 hours played
Written 16 days ago
It's fun, but I would be hard-pressed to recommend it until things improve. Game is basically still in Early Access. Boss relics are hot trash (a known issue since early access), the new bosses (Leshy and Pigment of Imagination) are massively overtuned still, and Cruciball 10+ (arguably 5+ or even lower) are incredibly frustrating and not fun.
Runs even on lower Cruciball levels can be extremely rng due to the relic pool drowning in garbage, extremely poor boss balance, terrible fight design (the ghost in the mines that only spawns a couple pegs every turn/refresh while hitting you constantly), among myriad other reasons.
Build variety is also nearly nonexistent. The pool of useful relics, especially those that kick-start your run, is dreadfully shallow, with most relics offering only small situational benefits, require a lot of work or synergy to accomplish anything, or the absolutely insulting +1/+0 and +0/+1 relics. Tragically, those latter two relics are actually decent-to-good to get early on because they bolster the godawful Pebball stats.
Now, I suppose to be fair, Slay the Spire also has problems with having some aggressively bad or really middling relics, a lot of iffy cards that require a magical Christmasland scenario to pop off, and some fights that are just aggravating. The difference is...StS is over 6 years old (probably older, considering it was an Early Access game).
Peglin entered 1.0 less than a year ago, long after StS came out. It was in Early Access as well, but not for as long, and it feels like it was shoved out into 1.0 more out of desperation or publisher obligation than because it was actually ready for primetime.
It's a game that has a really cute gimmick, and when you're finally allowed to have a run go well and feel a bunch of pieces falling into place, it definitely can feel good. But for every time you get a good run, there's going to be several more that are going to be slogs you're limping through or simply end because of some luck-based factor you can't influence.