20.9 hours played
Written 30 days ago
[h1] Summary [/h1]
I think that Chimera Squad gets a hard press. It's a flawed game, but still has good music, and interesting story, and a very different take on art-style and combat, which, as someone whose played the original UFO Defense, XCOM 1, EW, XCOM 2 and WOTC, was not necessarily a bad thing. I think it's an enjoyable game, just not a 'blow your mind' kind of game.
[h1] Mechanics & Lore [/h1]
Don't get me wrong, it's not as good as the other games, which I would maintain are some of the best turn based strategy games on the market, but the 'breach' mechanic that stops combat is interesting, it's fun being able to play as aliens (which only really would happen via mind control shenanigans in other games), and every character has their own personality, and issues.
I don't think City 31 as a concept is that far fetched - the Elder's did mind control and subjugate every race as they came to Earth, and the plotline does make it clear that 'living together', is a bit difficult.
I think what lets the game down the most is the limited voice acting lines and direction, and the lack of variety in combat. If you want to have personable characters, especially in combat systems, you need more variety in lines. You don't need that in StarCraft, for example, because you're listening for audio confirmation that the marine is selected, and that they're shooting. But if you're going to have each other comment on moves, bad plays, wounding, etc, you need more than 5-10 lines per character for a 20 hour game. Especially as most people will stick to the squad they made.
[h1] A Small Note on Enemies [/h1]
Secondly, I think they should've added more enemies. Each faction do have their own unique units, and there are some 'standard' henchmen for everyone, but quite a few are just repastes from XCOM 2. Cool ones, which are paced out well, which keep you on your toes, but its not that new.
[hr][/hr]
If you're looking for a fantastic game from the developers of XCOM, then this might not be it - consider modding the other titles. If you're looking for a different take on the formula, with comic book art style, then I think you would enjoy the game for what it is.